Canada has long been regarded as a beacon of opportunity, attracting immigrants worldwide with promises of stability, prosperity, and a high quality of life. Yet, a troubling trend has emerged: a growing number of skilled immigrants, including permanent residents, are leaving the country. This phenomenon, often referred to as “onward migration,” poses significant challenges to Canada’s economy and its global reputation as a welcoming nation.
Record Population Growth and Policy Reversals
Between 2023 and 2024, Canada experienced its largest population surge in history, growing by over a million people in just one year. This growth was largely driven by high immigration levels, international students, and temporary foreign workers. However, in response to concerns about housing and infrastructure strains, the Canadian government revised its immigration policies. Notably, it reduced permanent immigration targets for the first time in decades—from 500,000 to 395,000 by 2025. Despite this, the retention of existing immigrants, particularly those in the skilled economic class, remains a significant challenge, as many are leaving Canada within a few years of arrival.
Why Skilled Immigrants Are Leaving
Contrary to popular belief, the immigrants departing Canada are not those struggling to integrate. Instead, they are highly educated, multilingual professionals selected for their ability to meet Canada’s labor market needs. Many leave due to one or more of the following reasons:
1. Housing Affordability and Cost of Living
Canada’s housing crisis, particularly in urban centers like Toronto and Vancouver, has made it difficult for skilled workers to afford homes and build the life they envisioned. For many immigrants, the decision to leave for a more affordable country is driven by the high cost of living, which often outweighs the financial benefits of living in Canada.
2. Underemployment and Career Barriers
Many immigrants come with advanced degrees and professional experience but struggle to find jobs matching their qualifications. Barriers like regulatory red tape, credential recognition issues, and lack of Canadian work experience often lead them to underemployment, forcing them into low-paying or unrelated jobs. This underutilization of talent is a key factor driving immigrants to seek opportunities abroad.
3. Healthcare and Social Services
Canada’s healthcare system is also facing scrutiny due to long wait times and limited access to medical services. For immigrants who come from countries with more efficient healthcare systems, these issues can be a major deterrent.
4. Better Opportunities Abroad
Countries like the United States, Australia, and Germany offer higher salaries, faster immigration pathways, and more robust support systems for skilled workers. These nations are actively courting global talent, making them attractive alternatives to Canada.
The Economic Consequences of Onward Migration
The loss of skilled immigrants is not only a demographic concern but also an economic crisis in the making. Immigrants contribute significantly to Canada’s economy, filling labor shortages in critical sectors like healthcare, construction, and technology. Their departure could exacerbate existing workforce shortages and delay important projects, increasing costs. For instance:
- Healthcare: Immigrants make up a significant portion of Canada’s healthcare workforce. Their departure could worsen shortages of doctors, nurses, and other medical professionals.
- Construction and Trades: With an aging population and growing infrastructure needs, Canada relies heavily on immigrant workers in construction and skilled trades. Onward migration could delay vital projects and increase costs.
- Education and Early Childhood Care: Many immigrants work in education and childcare, sectors already facing labor shortages. Their absence could further strain these essential services.
Public Opinion: A Shift in Sentiment
Canada has historically enjoyed broad public support for immigration. However, recent surveys indicate growing skepticism, with many Canadians citing concerns about housing shortages, healthcare access, and job competition. This shift in sentiment has influenced the federal government’s decision to reduce immigration targets. Experts warn that this could lead to a “leaky bucket” scenario, where fewer immigrants are admitted, but those who arrive may not stay.
What Canada Can Do to Retain Immigrants
To address onward migration, Canada must focus on retaining immigrants as much as attracting them. Here are some key strategies:
1. Tackle Housing Affordability
Both federal and provincial governments should collaborate to increase the housing supply and improve affordability. Policies that incentivize affordable housing development and curb speculation could help immigrants find suitable homes.
2. Streamline Credential Recognition
Canada needs to simplify the process for recognizing foreign credentials. Accelerating this process would allow skilled immigrants to enter their fields faster and reduce underemployment.
3. Invest in Social Services
Adequate funding for healthcare, education, and childcare services is crucial to meeting the needs of a growing population. Improving these services can enhance the quality of life for both immigrants and native-born Canadians.
4. Enhance Support Programs
Settlement programs should not only focus on helping immigrants integrate but also on retaining them long-term. Initiatives such as mentorship programs, networking opportunities, and career support can make a significant difference in keeping skilled immigrants in Canada.
Free Settlement Services in Canada to Help New Immigrants Secure Employment
A Guide to Legal Online Betting for New Immigrants in Canada
Michael Barutciski: Is the Trudeau Government Truly Committed to Reducing Immigration?
Canada’s Immigration Backlog Sees a Decrease, According to New IRCC Update
New Canada Pension Plan (CPP) Payments to be Sent Nationwide on November 27
5. Promote Regional Immigration
Encouraging immigrants to settle in smaller communities, where housing is more affordable and job opportunities are abundant, could alleviate pressure on major cities. Programs like the Atlantic Immigration Program and Rural and Northern Immigration Pilot are steps in the right direction.
Leave a Reply